Triage audit: 30 open untriaged non-bug issues (May 2026, follow-up to #1964) #1965

This issue tracks an audit of 30 currently-open untriaged, non-type: bug issues, checked against master (v4.15.1). It is the follow-up to #1964 (which covered the 30 open type: bug issues). Together the two issues span 60 of the ~120 currently-open issues.

Findings are based on code inspection only — please confirm with a real reproduction or maintainer judgement before acting on any item.

✅ Likely fixed — verify & close

• Commitizen is not compatible with recent versions of ipython because of its dependency on questionary #1249 — questionary/ipython incompatibility — pyproject.toml:16 already pins questionary (>=2.0,<3.0) which works with current prompt_toolkit and recent ipython releases. Closed as fixed; see follow-up below.

❌ Still valid — needs implementation / fix

• Promote PR bump preview to a reusable workflow in setup-cz #1959 — Promote PR bump preview to a reusable workflow in setup-cz — feature not yet implemented; PR ci: add PR bump preview workflow #1957 only adds the workflow to this repo.
• [breaking] remove cmd.run string signature #1944 — Remove cmd.run string signature for v5 — commitizen/cmd.py:68-77 still accepts cmd: str | Sequence[str].
• Enable "--merge-prerelease" behavior in "cz bump" command #1934 — Enable --merge-prerelease on cz bump — commitizen/cli.py:433-440 defines the flag only under cz changelog. PR feat(bump): add --merge-prerelease flag #1968 was opened, then closed pending maintainer triage — feature requests sit with the maintainers for design / scope review.
• VersionIncrement related cleanup #1777 — Replace MAJOR/MINOR/PATCH string constants with VersionIncrement IntEnum — commitizen/bump.py:25 still uses find_increment() returning strings even though commitizen/version_increment.py already defines the enum.
• Separate version providers from core #1676 — Separate version providers into optional workspace packages — commitizen/providers/ ships 9 providers inline.
• MAJOR,MINOR,PATCH config that takes in consideration the branch #1572 — Branch-aware bump rules (cap min/max increment per branch pattern) — no branch-aware bump logic in codebase.
• Create a new package called commitizen-extras #1567 — Create a commitizen-extras repository for community plugins — organisational meta-issue.
• Release commitizen v5 #1481 — Release commitizen v5 — meta tracker; depends on remaining v5-labelled items being landed.
• Relative paths works differently with newer versions #1411 — Relative-path behaviour changed in 4.6.3+ — commitizen/commands/changelog.py:68 resolves the file path relative to the config parent when config.path exists.
• prepare-commit-msg pre-commit hook #1393 — Add a prepare-commit-msg hook entry — .pre-commit-hooks.yaml:1-28 only defines commit-msg and pre-push stages.
• Problem executing cz commit in prepare-commit-msg hook on Mac #1386 — cz commit fails inside a prepare-commit-msg hook on macOS — commitizen/commands/commit.py invokes questionary.prompt which requires a real TTY; selector errors when stdin is redirected.
• Global config that will be merged with repository config #1332 — Global config merge — commitizen/config/__init__.py:12-27 only walks the current directory and git root, never ~/.config/commitizen.toml.
• Command that generates current configuration file #1331 — cz dump-config / config export command — commitizen/commands/__init__.py lists Bump/Changelog/Check/Commit/Example/Info/Init/ListCz/Schema/Version only. PR feat: add cz dump-config command to output effective configuration #1986 was opened, then closed pending maintainer triage — feature requests sit with the maintainers for design / scope review.
• make everything in a cz_ customizable through toml/json and etc #1278 — Make every aspect of a cz_* plugin configurable through TOML/JSON — broad enhancement umbrella related to Enable cover cz_conventional_commits via [tool.commitizen.customize] #1270.
• Enable cover cz_conventional_commits via [tool.commitizen.customize] #1270 — Allow partially overriding cz_conventional_commits via [tool.commitizen.customize] — commitizen/cz/customize/customize.py:27 is a standalone class that does not inherit from ConventionalCommitsCz.
• The cz ch command generates a CHANGELOG.md that includes the content from the body. #1267 — cz changelog includes commit body lines that match the parser regex — commitizen/changelog.py:151-154 splits commit.body by \n\n and re-parses each block. PR fix(changelog): add changelog_subject_only to skip body parsing #1974 was opened, then closed pending maintainer triage — feature requests sit with the maintainers for design / scope review.
• Scan for providers using metadata.entry_points in init #1258 — Discover providers via metadata.entry_points in cz init — commitizen/commands/init.py:41,257 hardcodes _VERSION_PROVIDER_CHOICES. PR feat(init): discover third-party version providers via entry points #1971 was opened, then closed pending maintainer triage — feature requests sit with the maintainers for design / scope review.
• Add required parameter to Detailed questions content #1231 — Add required parameter to detailed customise questions — commitizen/question.py defines question types with no required validation field. PR feat(customize): add required field for input questions #1984 was opened, then closed pending maintainer triage — feature requests sit with the maintainers for design / scope review.
• CHANGELOG should only write down the main release  #1218 — Option to write only main releases (skip rc/dev) into the changelog — commitizen/commands/changelog.py:229-264 has prerelease merge logic but no full-exclude switch. PR feat: add changelog_skip_prereleases setting to omit prerelease entries from changelog #1985 was opened, then closed pending maintainer triage — feature requests sit with the maintainers for design / scope review.

🔧 Has open PR

• Enable multi-line commit body input #1917 — Multi-line commit body input — PR Support multi-line commit body input #1919 (pr-status: wait-for-review).
• Feat: interactive live subject preview #1901 — Interactive live subject preview — PR Feat: add live subject preview for interactive commit (--preview) #1902 (pr-status: wait-for-review).
• Discuss cz init self.config #1831 — cz init should use DEFAULT_SETTINGS instead of self.config.settings — PR refactor(init): replace self.config.settings with DEFAULT_SETTINGS #1832 (pr-status: wait-for-review).
• Generate expected bump version comment when receiving a new pull request #1510 — PR bump-preview workflow — PR ci: add PR bump preview workflow #1957 (pr-status: wait-for-review).

🎁 Mislabeled — relabel and remove issue-status: needs-triage

• [refactor] Make BaseConfig an abstract class #1847 — Make BaseConfig an abstract class — commitizen/config/base_config.py:18-61 is a concrete class with NotImplementedError stubs. Relabeled type: refactor.
• Add commit hash and issue number to the changelog format as optional variables #1229 — Add commit hash / issue number to changelog format — default-template feature; relabeled wait-for-implementation. (Existing template support via sha1 is documented but only works for custom templates.)
• Release after dev release results in error #1180 — Release after dev release results in error — commitizen/commands/changelog.py:151-155 SequenceMatcher picks the wrong closest tag for dev versions. Relabeled type: bug; analysis comment posted.

🤷 By design / config issue / non-bug — close with explanation

• Monorepo example using .cz.toml files #1334 — Monorepo example using .cz.toml files — docs/tutorials/monorepo_guidance.md already documents the multi-.cz.toml setup.
• output suppressed until pre-commit scripts fully ran #1333 — Output suppressed until pre-commit scripts finish — commitizen/cmd.py uses subprocess.Popen(..., PIPE) + communicate() to capture git output for error parsing; intentional buffering.

❔ Needs reproduction / unclear

• Running cz commit ends with "The system cannot find the path specified." #1419 — Windows "system cannot find the path specified" after commit — last reporter comment ("transient issue, not able to pinpoint") leaves the failure unreproduced; temp file lifecycle is in commitizen/git.py and commitizen/commands/commit.py.

Summary: 1 likely fixed (closed) · 19 still valid (3 of which now have PRs from this round) · 4 had open PRs at audit time · 3 mislabels · 2 by-design · 1 unclear.

Together with #1964: out of 60 audited open issues, 24 are still actionable bugs, 19 are still actionable feature/refactor requests, and 8 already have open PRs awaiting review. Round-3 audit: #1976.

Round-2 follow-up actions (May 2026)

Strong-model validation, label cleanup, PRs, and external review for the items checked above.

• Commitizen is not compatible with recent versions of ipython because of its dependency on questionary #1249 closed: validation by claude-opus-4.7 confirmed questionary 2.1.0 + commitizen master (questionary >=2.0,<3.0) co-installs cleanly with current ipython 8/9; the repo's own uv.lock resolves all three together.
• Enable "--merge-prerelease" behavior in "cz bump" command #1934 → PR feat(bump): add --merge-prerelease flag #1968 (feat(bump): add --merge-prerelease flag). CI green across the matrix. Reviewed by both an internal claude-sonnet-4.6 code-review agent and GitHub Copilot — no findings.
• Scan for providers using metadata.entry_points in init #1258 → PR feat(init): discover third-party version providers via entry points #1971 (feat(init): discover third-party version providers via entry points). CI green. Copilot review surfaced a duplicate-entry-point-name edge case (two distributions registering the same provider name); fixup commit 1bad9047 adds a seen_names set seeded with the built-ins and a regression test test_construct_version_provider_choices_dedupes_duplicate_third_party.
• The cz ch command generates a CHANGELOG.md that includes the content from the body. #1267 → PR fix(changelog): add changelog_subject_only to skip body parsing #1974 (fix(changelog): add changelog_subject_only to skip body parsing). CI green. Reviewers (sonnet-4.6 and Copilot) both flagged the same test gap: no end-to-end test for the config-key wiring at commands/changelog.py:279. Fixup commit 292feb4f adds tests/commands/test_changelog_command.py::test_changelog_subject_only_setting_skips_body_parsing which constructs a real cz changelog invocation; the new test was verified to fail (KeyError) when the config key is mistyped.
• [refactor] Make BaseConfig an abstract class #1847 relabeled type: feature → type: refactor, status → wait-for-implementation (maintainer comment confirms this is a v5 breaking change candidate, so leaving for the v5 release work in Release commitizen v5 #1481 rather than a separate PR).
• Add commit hash and issue number to the changelog format as optional variables #1229 relabeled needs-triage → wait-for-implementation, kept type: feature (the audit had proposed type: documentation, but a closer read of the issue shows the user wants sha1 / issue links in the default changelog template; existing template support is only a workaround).
• Release after dev release results in error #1180 — added type: bug and wait-for-implementation; posted a comment with the SequenceMatcher analysis so a future fixer has clear direction. Not PR'd because the design choice (exact-match vs fuzzy-fallback) deserves a maintainer call.

Issues left to a maintainer (no PR opened yet):

• prepare-commit-msg pre-commit hook #1393 / Problem executing cz commit in prepare-commit-msg hook on Mac #1386 — prepare-commit-msg hook entry would be a one-line YAML addition, but the underlying cz commit interactive flow fails on macOS in such a hook (Problem executing cz commit in prepare-commit-msg hook on Mac #1386), so adding the entry without addressing the TTY behaviour would just relocate the bug.
• [breaking] remove cmd.run string signature #1944 — removing the cmd.run string signature is a breaking change scheduled for v5; better landed alongside the rest of v5.
• All remaining "still valid" items in the table above.

Happy to take individual items off this list — please comment with which # you're picking up.

Policy update (2026-05-09) — feature-request issues are not auto-PR'd from this triage. PRs #1968, #1971, #1974, #1984, #1985, #1986 (each opened to close one of the feature items above) have been re-closed and the corresponding issue labels reverted to issue-status: needs-triage. The implementation branches are preserved on the fork (feat/1934-bump-merge-prerelease-flag, feat/1258-init-discover-providers, fix/1267-changelog-subject-only, feat/1231-customize-question-required, fix/1218-changelog-skip-prereleases, feat/1331-dump-config-command) so a maintainer can re-open any of them with one click if they decide the direction is right. Bug-fix PRs from this triage (#1979, #1982, #1987 — plus the round-1 sibling bug-fix PRs in #1964) remain open.