Repository navigation
Make repl autocomplete case-insensitive #41631
Description
What is the problem this feature will solve?
Having an autocomplete in the REPL is already a great feature, but currently the autocomplete is case-sensitive, which means that if you are not quite sure about variable names or typing too fast to case your input properly you might miss out on the benefits of having an autocomplete aiding you in your typing.
What is the feature you are proposing to solve the problem?
Make autocomplete case-insensitive.
Specifically I'm suggesting not to make it completely case-insensitive, but follow console behavior in browsers (at least Chrome and FF that I used as reference) that Node.js REPL users might be most familiar with already.
These browsers make autocomplete suggestions ignoring the input case if the first char of the last member in the input that autocomplete is trying to complete is lower-cased, otherwise, if the char is upper-cased, browser will use input casing when filtering autocomplete suggestions.
To illustrate this behavior:
> var xa = '123';
> var Xb = { fooBar: 1, FooBuz: 2 }
> x <tab>
xa Xb
> X <tab>
(autocompletes to `Xb` because it's the only possible option)
> Xb.f <tab>
Xb.FooBuz Xb.fooBar
> Xb.F <tab>
(autocompletes to `Xb.FooBuz` because it's the only possible option)
> Xb.Foob <tab>
(no autocomplete suggestions because suggestions are preserving case)I also opened a PR with a possible implementation of this autocomplete change #41632
What alternatives have you considered?
Make autocomplete completely case-insensitive. Totally an option, but in my opinion browser behavior makes sense: if you are using uppercase in your input, this seems like a good indicator that you are very intentional about it and autocomplete suggestions should respect that.
Preserve current behavior. Worth mentioning because changing autocomplete to be case-insensitive while helpful in some cases, might introduce more autocomplete noise and inconvenience in others. For example typing func <tab> will not autocomplete to function anymore because Function will be a matching suggestion
Activity
benjamingr commentedon Jan 21, 2022
@nodejs/repl
benjamingr commentedon Jan 21, 2022
For what it's worth Chrome will suggest
Functionbut will autocompletefunctofunctionwhen you . I'm wondering how many such cases there are and if they can be fixed ad-hoc.gribnoysup commentedon Jan 22, 2022
Yep, true that! Even more generally, but feels like worth adding to that: opposed to how Node.js REPL behaves in the case of multiple suggestions browser console will still autocomplete to the first suggetion when you
<tab>or<right>for any autocomplete suggestion with multiple suggestions, so cases similar to thisfunction/Functionone can be avoided. I think some terminals do a similar thing where tabbing when multiple autocompletes are possible would work as selecting from the list of autocomplete options. Would be great to have something like this in Node.js REPL too, maybe worth having it as a separate feature request?repl: make autocomplete case-insensitive
repl: make autocomplete case-insensitive
repl: make autocomplete case-insensitive
repl: make autocomplete case-insensitive
nsauk commentedon Apr 28, 2024
This made my experience worse. It's common to have something like this in your snippets:
When autocomplete is case-insensitive, you cannot choose the right option from these above: